Senator Lindsay Graham (R-SC) (linked to that McCain guy. No, not The Other McCain) in his appearance on Meet the Press this morning was asked if more stimulus was needed for this economy, and this was his response:
I've got people in South Carolina who are thinking about buying a car but are having a very difficult time getting a car loan. But their biggest fear is they think they may get laid off in the next six months. So if we could get credit flowing in the consumer areas, I think it would stabilize the economy more than anything else.
How exactly is getting credit flowing to unworthy borrowers going to stabilize the economy? I’m just some young (dirty) blond chick, what do I know? I may be wrong here but, it seems to me, if your biggest fear is that you think you may be laid off in the next six months, you probably shouldn’t be thinking about buying a car. I’m just saying.
I understand that we are having some “economic difficulties,” to say the least. Here’s the thing, I don’t seem to be having any problems getting credit. In fact, just last week one of my credit cards increased my credit line without me requesting it. I attribute this to the fact that I live within my means and pay all of my bills in full and on time. I could be wrong, though. It might just be because I’m white.
Here’s what I think is happening. Those who are creditworthy will receive credit for whatever they are deemed capable of paying back. If you are try to buy a car when you think you may get laid off within the next six months, I have a sneaking suspicion, the lender may have that same inclination about your fate. In this event, if they looked into their crystal ball, they might deny you for that loan.
For example, banks (now, members of Congress like B.Frank) used to decide who was creditworthy when it came to buying houses. Then, Congress stepped in. There were people who wanted to own a home and were denied based on their creditworthiness. Then Congress decided the American Dream is really an American right and created a situation that allowed banks to loan money to borrowers who should not have been buying a home, or should have been more modest in their home buying. I can’t remember how that movie ended, exactly, but I’m pretty sure it wasn’t a happy one.
Spoiler alert: banks are better at determining who is creditworthy than politicians on Capitol Hill. People who are worried about losing their job in six months have no business buying a new car; just as those who bought houses over the past couple of years who couldn’t afford them should have either a) bought more affordable housing or, b) continued to rent.
The problem, at this point, is not credit. The market is operating exactly how it should be in the current economic climate. The problem is the people and the politicians who insist we can spend our way out of this. If you can’t afford something, don’t buy it (yes, Congress, that means you, too!). ! It’s as simple as that. The beauty is, it has always been that simple. The shocker is, no one seems willing to accept this.
This comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDelete"I attribute this to the fact that I live within my means and pay all of my bills in full and on time. I could be wrong, though. It might just be because I’m white."
ReplyDeleteI think its more likely you have good credit because you are (dirty) Blond. [joking]
Excellent analysis. That Lindsay Graham would make such a moronic comment shows once again that Republicans still don't get it, and continue to act like Democrats Lite. I wonder how many years in the wilderness it will take before they realize that given a choice between the Lite version and the real thing, voters will continue to select the latter.
ReplyDeleteIt really is that simple--I'm not sure why these knuckleheads don't get it.
ReplyDeleteThey act as if the market won't immediately adjust to whatever "fix" they try to make next just like it has adjusted to all the others.
Right first time: the uncreditworthy are not worthy of being bailed out. Bailing out those who couldn't figure out how to run their financial situation will not be improved by government money thrown at them. Shifting bad debt to the government makes the government less solvent and leaves the bad regulations and mandates in place to re-cause the problem.
ReplyDeleteWe haven't learned that the fastest way to stop an increasing headache is to stop hitting your head against a brick wall. And we will all pay for that.
You are much smarter than the young (dirty) blond chicks I know.
ReplyDeleteVery much so.
:)
I'm retired and keep getting offers for credit lines. I'm refinancing and other than a communication problem in the loan office, since corrected by me, I am not having a problem. It is interesting that with computers and networking galore, information seems to be more difficult to pass on to other levels of the loan approval system. I can't wait for the promised computerization of our entire medical system.
ReplyDeleteYou are so right. One of the main reasons we are in this economic pickle is that banks made or were forced by CRA rules to make loans to uncredit worthy borrowers.
ReplyDeleteCongress is full of well meaning idiots, pandering idiots and self serving corrupt idiots. Giving money to people who have no way to pay it back or no intention of paying it back is the function of CHARITY, not the function of business.
So Congress chastises the Banks and Lenders for not making money and threatens to sieze their companies while at the same time demanding that they give away cash with no hope of profit. Smart hmmmmm???
Well put, young lady.
ReplyDeleteBut why are they worried about losing their jobs in the next six months if they weren't worried about losing their jobs in the next six months six months ago? Yeah.
ReplyDeleteYeah, those poor, poor bankers only made bad loans because the Feds forced them. Noxious securitization and poor underwriting practices had NOTHING to do with this mess, right?
ReplyDeleteAnd, please, spare us the unemployed straw men in Lindsay Graham's district. During the fourth quarter last year, there were NO auto loans for ANYONE. In November last year, if you didn't have a credit score of 780+, you weren't even considered for a loan.
CRA contributed to this mess. The rivers of funny money flowing from the Federal Reserve contributed to this mess. Stupid banking practices contributed to this mess. Poor risk management on Wall Street contributed to this mess. Not understanding counterparties... well, you get the picture.
Or not.
Does seem slightly obvious. The main problem I see is that the government can 'make' someone creditworthy and paddle us farther down this creek. If I get part of my mortgage forgiven I get to talk to the IRS about it. If government forgives a note, offers a basket of food, or sends a check, they don't bother to notify the IRS with a 1099. Too bad. It would be nice to know where all our money is going. I guess all that money they get in taxes really IS their money!
ReplyDeleteI think this SNL skit really says it all, "Don't Buy Stuff You Cannot Afford":
ReplyDeletehttp://www.hulu.com/watch/1389/saturday-night-live-dont-buy-stuff
So, we have this banking crisis caused by lending too much money to people who couldn't pay it back, and the "solution" is to lend a whole lotta MO' MONEY MO' MONEY MO' MONEY to people who can't pay it back. Makes perfect sense - if you happen to be a Democrat or an idiot (but, I repeat myself).
ReplyDeleteSay what you will about Lindsey Graham but, if it were not for him, WHO would fetch John McCain's tea and slippers and press his trousers, hmmmm? Answer me that!